May 17, 2012

Facebook Ad Images: You’re Doing It Wrong

Recently I’ve been reading through the book “Killer Facebook Ads“(disclosure: affiliate link) by Marty Weintraub of aimClear. The guy is probably the smartest Facebook advertiser out there. I got to hear him speak at Pubcon earlier this month and the book lets you consume the info at your own pace. But I digress…

Marty points out that a Facebook ad image needs to accomplish two major objectives:

  1. Cut through the clutter/attract attention
  2. Lend context to the headline or vice versa

At almost the same time I was reading about this (page 140 if you’re curious) I came across the following ad in my own Facebook account:

Facebook Ad Image Fail

I acknowledge that the ad successfully accomplished objective #1 because I noticed it. No small task for an internet marketer who is more well trained at ignoring ads than most. But the ad fails so miserably on objective #2 I had to post about it. So how did if fail? Let me count the ways:

  • Members of the LDS church believe in modesty – the low cut tank top is sending the wrong message
  • Tattoos are discouraged by the LDS church – this girl has more ink than a printer cartridge (and that’s just what you can see)

Basically, this image produces mental friction because the copy is talking about LDS dating, yet the image is in opposition to the connotation of LDS dating. I don’t know if this was a test and maybe this image got a better CTR, but my guess is that it failed to convert traffic because the message from the ad copy didn’t align with the message of the image. Your thoughts?

About Robert

Conversion rate optimization and PPC wizard. If I'm not out playing ultimate frisbee or golf you may find me hiking, skiing or mountain biking.